Our Latest Blogs

Mental Health Chatbots: How to Use Them Safely Without Replacing Your Therapist

Young woman using smartphone for mental health support while sitting thoughtfully on couch.

It’s late at night, everyone else is asleep, and your thoughts are racing. You know you probably need to talk to someone, but your next therapy session isn’t for another week, and you don’t want to wake a friend. So you reach for your phone and open a mental health chatbot.

For many people, that scene is already part of everyday life. Digital tools and AI are moving quickly into the space that used to belong only to hotlines, clinics, and therapists’ offices. Health organizations see huge potential in digital mental health, but they’ve also been very clear that these tools need strong safeguards and human oversight.

Chatbots are not going away. The real question is how to use them in ways that support recovery, without letting them take the place of real-world care.

What Are Mental Health Chatbots?

People often use the word chatbot to mean different things:

  • General AI chatbots – tools such as ChatGPT or other large language models that can talk about almost anything, including mental health, even though they weren’t designed for that role.
  • Purpose-built mental health apps – apps that offer structured programs, mood tracking, and brief conversations based on therapies like cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), often with programmed responses.
  • Clinic-integrated assistants – tools that some services are now piloting to help patients reflect between sessions, remember homework, or prepare questions for their therapist, with clinicians involved in the design and oversight.

All of these options involve talking to software that feels conversational and responsive. That can be comforting. It can also blur the line between “digital tool” and “therapist” in ways that create real risks.

Real Benefits of Mental Health Chatbots When Used Properly

There is now a growing body of research on chatbot-based mental health tools. Overall, studies suggest they can offer meaningful, if modest, improvements in problem areas such as anxiety, low mood, and stress, especially for people who might otherwise have no support at all.

In everyday language, here’s what that looks like:

Support When No One Is Available

At 2 am, your therapist is asleep, but a chatbot is not. For some people, having something to talk to in that moment is enough to feel a little less alone.

Practice Between Sessions

Many apps use techniques from CBT and related therapies. They can walk you through reframing a thought, planning a coping strategy for the next day, or doing a short relaxation exercise. Doing this between sessions can make your time with a human therapist more effective.

Lower Barrier to Starting

Talking to software can feel less intimidating than talking to a person. For people who are anxious, ashamed, or worried about stigma, that anonymous first step can be the thing that eventually leads them to ask for human help.

Structure and Reminders

Some tools are good at tracking mood, sleep, and physical activity, then turning the results into graphs and gentle nudges. It can be easier to bring that data into therapy than relying solely on memory.

Used in these ways, chatbots can act like interactive workbooks – not a therapist, but a tool that makes therapy easier to start and stick with.

Why Mental Health Chatbots Should Never Replace Your Therapist

At the same time, there are very real reasons why mental health professionals warn against treating AI like a stand-alone therapist.

A few key limits matter:

No License, No Duty of Care

A human therapist is trained, registered, supervised, and held to ethical standards. They have a legal and professional duty to act in your best interests. A chatbot, even a very sophisticated one, does not. If it gives you poor or harmful advice, there is usually no clear accountability.

Inconsistent Safety in Crisis Situations

Studies and media reports have shown that some chatbots respond in unsafe or unhelpful ways when people talk about suicide or self-harm. Even when they do recognize risk, they can only give general crisis information or signpost to hotlines. They can’t call emergency services, assess your safety in person, or speak to your family.

They Can Sound Confident While Being Wrong

Large language models are very good at sounding certain. They are not always good at being correct. When the topic is your medication, your diagnosis, or your safety, that gap really matters.

Privacy and Data Concerns

Many mental health apps collect detailed information about your emotions, habits, and vulnerabilities. Reviews of digital mental health tools have repeatedly raised concerns about how that data is stored, shared, or used for commercial purposes.

Because of these limits, a simple rule of thumb is: a chatbot can be a practice space and a prompt, but it should not be the place where major treatment decisions are made.

If you are in immediate distress, feeling unsafe, or thinking about ending your life, a chatbot is not the right place to turn. Contact your local crisis line (for example, the 988 Lifeline in the United States), call emergency services (911 in the US), or reach out to a trusted person who can help you get urgent support.

How to Use Mental Health Chatbots Safely: Practical Guidelines

So what does “safe enough” use actually look like in everyday life? Here are some ideas you can adapt to your own situation.

Decide What the Chatbot Is For – And What It Isn’t

You might choose to use it for activities such as journaling, tracking moods, or practicing coping skills. You might decide it is not for advice on medication changes, big life decisions, or crisis planning. Writing this down can help keep the boundaries clear when you’re overwhelmed.

Tell Your Therapist You’re Using It

If you’re already in therapy, let your clinician know what digital tools you use and what you talk about with them. Many therapists would rather help you evaluate and integrate a chatbot than have you use one in secret and feel confused about mixed messages.

Double-Check Chatbot Advice

Any time a chatbot suggests something that could significantly affect your health, relationships, safety, or finances, treat it as a draft idea – not a plan. Bring it to your next session, or check it with a trusted professional or support person.

Use It to Prepare for Sessions, Not to Replace Them

Before therapy, you might use a chatbot to sort through your week: “What actually bothered me most?” “What did I try that helped?” Jot down key themes and bring them in. This approach helps you get more value from your therapy sessions.

Protect Your Privacy

Before sharing anything sensitive, check the app’s privacy notice. If you can’t easily understand where your data goes, treat that as a warning sign. Avoid sending things like full names, addresses, identification numbers, or detailed information about other people without their consent.

Watch for Over-Reliance on Chatbots

If you notice you’re spending hours a day with the chatbot or feeling more attached to it than to people in your life, that’s something to take seriously. It might be a sign to reduce your use, involve your therapist, or look for more human connection.

How Clinics Can Build Safer Mental Health Chatbot Tools

Some services are now experimenting with ways to use AI within well-governed, real-world care. Emerging guidelines recommend involving clinicians and people with lived experience in the design, being explicit about what the chatbot can and cannot do, and regularly checking its responses for safety and quality.

At Therapy Near Me, we are piloting an AI-assisted psychology companion called psAIch to help clients track patterns between sessions and remember questions they want to bring to therapy. It does not make diagnoses or treatment decisions, and everything it does is overseen by human psychologists. At the same time, we are investing in greener technology like our AirVolt renewable energy system, because running AI responsibly is not only about psychological safety – we are also concerned about the environmental impact of the computing power behind these tools.

This kind of model is still evolving, and no system is perfect. But it points to a future where digital helpers are clearly framed as part of a human-led team, not a competitor to it.

Keeping the Heart of Recovery Human

For many people, chatbots are already part of how they cope: a late-night outlet, a place to rehearse coping skills, or a way to feel a little less alone between appointments. There is nothing weak or wrong about wanting that kind of support.

The key is to keep perspective.

A chatbot can help you put feelings into words; it cannot sit with you in a waiting room, notice the way you shrink into yourself when you talk about a trauma, or catch something in your tone of voice that doesn’t match your words. It cannot advocate for you at school, the workplace, or with a family member. It does not wake up in the middle of the night worrying about you.

Recovery is still built on human connection, good information, and access to qualified care. If we treat mental health chatbots as tools that sit alongside that – not instead of it – they can be a helpful part of the journey rather than a risky detour away from it.

Wondering how to balance digital mental health tools with professional care? Our Resource Specialists offer free, personalized guidance to help you find qualified therapists and appropriate technology resources in your community.

Contact a Resource Specialist

About the Author: Alexander Amatus is Business Development Lead at TherapyNearMe.com.au, Australia’s fastest growing national mental health service. He works at the intersection of clinical operations, AI-enabled care pathways, and sustainable digital infrastructure.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mental Health Chatbots

Mental health chatbots can be safe when used appropriately as a supplement to professional care, not a replacement. They work best for practicing coping skills, journaling, or mood tracking between therapy sessions. However, they lack professional accountability, may respond poorly in crisis situations, and can give inaccurate advice while sounding confident. Always verify important suggestions with a licensed therapist.
No. Mental health chatbots should never replace professional therapy. Unlike licensed therapists, chatbots have no duty of care, cannot assess your safety in person, and aren’t held to ethical standards. They work best as a supplemental tool – like an interactive workbook – that supports your work with a human therapist, not as a stand-alone treatment.
No. If you’re in immediate distress, feeling unsafe, or thinking about ending your life, contact your local crisis line (such as the 988 Lifeline in the United States), call emergency services (911 in the US), or reach out to a trusted person. Chatbots cannot call emergency services, assess your immediate safety, or provide the urgent human support you need in a crisis.
Yes. If you’re in therapy, let your clinician know what digital tools you use and what you discuss with them. Many therapists prefer to help you evaluate and integrate a chatbot rather than have you use one in secret. Your therapist can help you make sense of any conflicting advice and ensure the chatbot supports your overall treatment goals.
Warning signs include spending hours daily with the chatbot or feeling more attached to it than to real people in your life. If you notice these patterns, it’s time to reduce your use, discuss it with your therapist, or seek more human connection. Mental health chatbots should enhance your relationships and recovery, not replace them.

Photo by Karola G: https://www.pexels.com/photo/teenage-girl-sitting-on-sofa-while-holding-cellphone-7283638/

The opinions and views expressed in any guest blog post do not necessarily reflect those of www.rtor.org or its sponsor, Laurel House, Inc. The author and www.rtor.org have no affiliations with any products or services mentioned in the article or linked to therein. Guest Authors may have affiliations to products mentioned or linked to in their author bios.

Recommended for You

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *